This is a ranking of bourbons only reviewed on Bourbon Notes. It is not meant as a comprehensive ranking of all bourbons. Everyone has different tastes and any list is subjective. We would like to hear you thoughts about the rankings.
#1 Michter's 10 Year -- 96 (Locked Cabinet)
#2 Blanton's -- 95 (Top Shelf)
#3 Four Roses Small Batch -- 95 (Top Shelf)
#4 Old Forester Prohibition -- 94 (Top Shelf)
#5 Four Roses Single Barrel -- 93 (Top Shelf)
#6 Henry McKenna 10 Year -- 92 (Top Shelf)
#7 Basil Hayden 10 Year -- 92 (Top Shelf)
#8 Rebel Yell 10 Year -- 90 (Top Shelf)
#9 Michter's Small Batch -- 90 (Middle Shelf)
#10 Wild Turkey Longbranch -- 89 (Middle Shelf)
#11 Evan Williams "Black Label" -- 89 (Bottom Shelf)
#12 Hancock Presidential Reserve -- 89 (Middle Shelf)
#13 Elijah Craig Small Batch -- 88 (Middle Shelf)
#14 J.T.S. Brown -- 88 (Bottom Shelf)
#15 Evan Williams Single Barrel -- 88 (Middle Shelf)
#16 1792 Small Batch -- 87 (Middle Shelf)
#17 Calumet Farms -- 85 (Top Shelf)
#18 Old Forester Single Barrel -- 84 (Middle Shelf)
#19 Johnny Drum -- 82 (Middle Shelf)
#20 Jim Beam Repeal Batch -- 69 (Bottom Shelf)
* This is a living list and will be updated as more reviews are posted.
#1 Michter's 10 Year -- 96 (Locked Cabinet)
#2 Blanton's -- 95 (Top Shelf)
#3 Four Roses Small Batch -- 95 (Top Shelf)
#4 Old Forester Prohibition -- 94 (Top Shelf)
#5 Four Roses Single Barrel -- 93 (Top Shelf)
#6 Henry McKenna 10 Year -- 92 (Top Shelf)
#7 Basil Hayden 10 Year -- 92 (Top Shelf)
#8 Rebel Yell 10 Year -- 90 (Top Shelf)
#9 Michter's Small Batch -- 90 (Middle Shelf)
#10 Wild Turkey Longbranch -- 89 (Middle Shelf)
#11 Evan Williams "Black Label" -- 89 (Bottom Shelf)
#12 Hancock Presidential Reserve -- 89 (Middle Shelf)
#13 Elijah Craig Small Batch -- 88 (Middle Shelf)
#14 J.T.S. Brown -- 88 (Bottom Shelf)
#15 Evan Williams Single Barrel -- 88 (Middle Shelf)
#16 1792 Small Batch -- 87 (Middle Shelf)
#17 Calumet Farms -- 85 (Top Shelf)
#18 Old Forester Single Barrel -- 84 (Middle Shelf)
#19 Johnny Drum -- 82 (Middle Shelf)
#20 Jim Beam Repeal Batch -- 69 (Bottom Shelf)
* This is a living list and will be updated as more reviews are posted.